What Are The Benefits of Just Moving the Ball Back?Teams will have a slightly higher incentive to go for two, but not as much as they would if the ball had been moved back to, say, the 30, or if the line of scrimmage had been left where it was and the player who scored the touchdown had to make the kick. Can you imagine Marshawn Lynch lining up to kick an extra point after scoring a touchdown? Or Dez Bryant throwing up another X after nailing his kick?
The NFL needs to go further to make this more difficult. One thing would be to make the uprights narrower. They tried this in the 2015 Pro Bowl, making them 14 feet wide instead of the current 18 feet, 6 inches. Kickers went two for three on field goal attempts and four for six on PATs. Even just shrinking them to 16 feet wide would help to reduce the rate of success on 45-yard field goals or longer, which is now well over two thirds. This would make coaches do some more thinking when they face fourth down near the opponent’s 30 or 35. More of them would go for it on fourth down, adding more drama to a game that gets pedestrian at times. Another benefit of this would be more punts, which are often exciting – if they’re returned. Making a rule that punted balls are dead at the point where they hit the ground, rather than making the punting team chase them down, would incentivize returns. Teams would likely have to put two people back to return them, leading to more returns in the open field and fewer fair catches. Teams might try more line drive punts to get more distance and give the returners less time to get under them and catch them. Punting at that lower trajectory could lead to more blocked punts – another exciting play.